By Bob Broad, Linda Adler-Kassner, Barry Alford, Jane Detweiler, Heidi Estrem, Susanmarie Harrington, Maureen McBride, Eric Stalions, Scott Weeden

Educators try to create “assessment cultures” within which they combine review into instructing and studying and fit evaluation equipment with top tutorial perform. yet how do academics and directors detect and negotiate the values that underlie their reviews? Bob Broad’s 2003 quantity, What we actually Value, brought dynamic standards mapping (DCM) as a style for eliciting locally-informed, context-sensitive standards for writing checks. The impression of DCM on overview perform is commencing to come to be increasingly more writing departments and courses undertake, adapt, or scan with DCM approaches.

For the authors of Organic Writing Assessment, the DCM event supplied not just an genuine evaluate in their personal courses, yet a nuanced language wherein they could speak within the constantly vexing, probably divisive realm of evaluation concept and perform. Of equivalent curiosity are the variations those writers invented for Broad’s unique technique, to make DCM much more attentive to neighborhood wishes and exigencies.

Organic Writing Assessment represents an enormous step within the evolution of writing evaluation in larger schooling. This quantity files the second one new release of an evaluation version that's considered as scrupulously in keeping with present conception; it indicates DCM’s flexibility, and offers an educated dialogue of its limits and its potentials.

Show description

Read Online or Download Organic Writing Assessment: Dynamic Criteria Mapping in Action PDF

Similar pedagogy books

What We Really Value: Beyond Rubrics in Teaching and Assessing Writing

As worthwhile as they've been, the nice weak spot of departmental writing rubrics lies in what they pass over. They current a handful of inarguably vital standards in which writing will be evaluated, yet they fail to remember dozens of alternative standards (such as "interest," "tone," or "commitment") in which any rhetorical functionality is additionally prone to be judged.

Teaching Composition As A Social Process

McComiskey argues for educating writing as located in discourse itself, within the consistent movement of texts produced inside of social relationships and associations. this can be a paintings with a cosmopolitan idea base and whole of examples from McComiskey's personal study rooms.

Resisting Linguistic Imperialism in English Teaching (Oxford Applied Linguistics)

This booklet explores how English is utilized in outer edge groups, whereas subtly resisting the linguistic imperialism from the worldwide ELT company.

Becoming an Evidence-based Practitioner: A Framework for Teacher-Researchers

This e-book is for academics who're having a look, or being inspired, to adopt learn of their colleges. Written through lecturers and their HE learn mentors, the ebook exhibits lecturers find out how to 'do' and 'use' learn and the way to 'do' powerful pedagogy.

Extra info for Organic Writing Assessment: Dynamic Criteria Mapping in Action

Sample text

3. What did we value about the assignment? 4. What would we change/revise in the assignment? -HJ\S[` TLTILYZ HJYVZZ [OL KPZJPWSPULZ JVSSHIVYH[LK [V KL]LSVW H ¸JVTTVU L]HS\H[PVU Z[YH[LN`¹ ]PZ\HSS` KLWPJ[LK PU 44**»Z K`UHTPJ JYP[LYPH THW ;OL ¸44** :[\KLU[ 6\[JVTLZ =HS\LZ¹ THW ^OPJO MHJPSP[H[LZ PU[LYKLWHY[TLU[HS HUK MHJ\S[`Z[\KLU[ KPZJ\ZZPVUZ JVUJLYUPUN ZOHYLK HZZLZZTLU[ JYP[LYPH OPNO SPNO[Z [OL ]LY` ILZ[ [OH[ JVTT\UHS ^YP[PUN HZZLZZTLU[ *>( WLKHNVN` OHZ [V VMMLY (JJVYKPUN [V )YVHK    *>( WYP]PSLNLZ JVSSHIVYH[P]L KLJP ZPVUTHRPUN HZZLZZTLU[ WYVJLZZLZ :[HSPVUZ Under Bob Broad’s direction, the faculty produced almost 200 hundred responses to the student samples.

Michigan has had an exit exam for high school students for a decade, and the students that go to community colleges have not been well served by it. It was important that assessment enrich instruction and not just serve external agencies or provide a “score” that told us little about the real capabilities of the student. ;OL 4PK 4PJOPNHU *VTT\UP[` *VSSLNL 44** L_WLYPLUJL PZ HU PTWVY[HU[ VUL MVY JYP[PJZ VM +*4 [V JVUZPKLY 0[ PZ LHZ` [V YLHK H KLZJYPW[PVU VM +*4 HUK [OPUR ¸^L»K UL]LY OH]L [PTL MVY [OH[¹ VY ¸T` JVSSLHN\LZ ^V\SK UL]LY NV MVY [OH[·[OL`»YL HSYLHK` [VV I\Z`¹ )HYY` HUK OPZ JVSSLHN\LZ Z\NNLZ[ [OH[ +*4 WYV]PKLZ H ^H` WHZ[ [OL IHYYPLY VM [PTL JVUZ[YHPU[Z [OH[ VM[LU MY\Z[YH[LZ PUP[PHS HZZLZZTLU[ LMMVY[Z +*4 WYVJLLKZ MYVT ^OH[ PZ HSYLHK` [OLYL LUJV\YHNPUN MHJ\S[` [V Z[HY[ ^P[O ^OH[ [OL` HYL HSYLHK` KVPUN JYLH[PUN Z[YLUN[OZ MYVT LHJO KLWHY[TLU[ VY WYVNYHT»Z KPZ[PUJ[P]L MLH[\YLZ /HYYPUN[VU HUK >LLKLU Another motivating factor for trying to use DCM was the experience those of use in the writing program had with our portfolio project.

Willingness to use multiple approaches to a problem i. Learning to see conflict as productive ii. Willingness to engage a problem from more than one viewpoint iii. Willingness to see value and credibility in divergent viewpoints iv. Respecting alternative views c. Pattern recognition i. Generalizing ii. Connecting iii. Synthesis iv. Creative patterns d. Using critical reasoning i. Use of sources and evidence ii. Drawing connections and conflicts iii. Creating a ‘third’ space +*4 HZ [OL (ZZLZZTLU[ 7YVNYHT  7 / ( : , ; > 6 !

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.05 of 5 – based on 10 votes